top of page

After contributing to the industry about how AI is being used in Google Paid search.

Given the growing interest in this topic, we decided to share my insights here. At Leaders in Digital (LiD), we work with a diverse range of ad campaigns and we have carried out extensive testing and research.

Search Campaign Tests Carried Out By Leaders in Digital

At Leaders in Digital (LiD), we conducted extensive tests across various campaigns using AI-generated content, human-created content, and a blend of both. The results revealed a significant difference in performance, with mixed content consistently outperforming the other two approaches.

Key Findings:

  • AI-Generated Content: Efficient but lacked the nuanced creativity needed for high engagement, as well as unique and strategic business requirements

  • Human-Created Content: Rich in creativity and understanding but less efficient in data-driven insights.

  • Mixed Content (AI and Human): Leveraged the strengths of both, resulting in higher engagement, better conversion rates, and more impactful ad resonance.

The combination of AI and human expertise proved to be the optimal strategy for achieving superior marketing results.

The Power of Human Expertise

Despite the efficiencies brought by AI, our testing shows that human oversight and creativity are crucial. AI tools are great for ideas but cannot replace data driven strategies or Google search data and they do not replace the need for skilled marketers who can:

  • Refine and Improve AI-Generated Content: AI provides a foundation, but human expertise is necessary to elevate the quality of ad copy and imagery.

  • Develop Unique Strategies: Human insight is essential for crafting strategies that resonate with target audiences and stand out from the competition.

  • Adapt and Innovate: The dynamic nature of digital marketing requires a human touch to adapt and innovate in response to changing trends and consumer behaviours.

The Future of AI in Marketing

AI is disrupting media and marketing results, and it does not replace the expertise and creativity of skilled marketers. As AI becomes more widespread, it is so important that you know either your agency or your team are not using AI to generate your paid media copy or content as this could be detrimental to your brand.

Yes it is fast, Yes it saves time…

However alone it will not drive results

extensive testing across different campaigns consistently shows that the combination of AI and human touch delivers superior results.

If you're ready to discuss enhancing your digital strategy or want more details on how these approaches can be applied to your organisation, please feel free to let me know and we can book a strategy call.


Dawn & the LiD Team

Updated: Jun 3

Are you leveraging AI-generated content in your SEO and marketing strategies? Have you considered how effective AI content is in enhancing your visibility on Google? As the digital landscape evolves, it’s crucial to understand the dynamics between AI-generated content and Google's search algorithms.

Google continuously updates its algorithms to prioritize high-quality, user-focused content. Recent insights from Search Engine Journal indicate significant shifts in Google’s approach, emphasizing the need for content that genuinely serves user intent rather than merely catering to algorithmic cues. This evolution is partly driven by the introduction of advanced machine learning tools like RankBrain, which help Google better understand and rank web content based on its relevance and quality.

The Role of Human Touch in AI SEO Content

But what does this mean for AI-generated content? Can it pass the rigorous tests of Google’s sophisticated algorithms? The answer isn't straightforward. While AI has become a powerful tool for generating content at scale, Google’s algorithms are increasingly designed to discern the depth, nuance, and value that typically come from human-generated content. This shift underscores a fundamental principle: the human touch in content creation is irreplaceable, especially in an era where authenticity and user engagement are paramount.

Moreover, Google’s recent algorithm updates have shown a clear intent to reduce the visibility of low-quality, AI-generated content. According to Search Engine Journal, these updates aim to decrease unoriginal or superficial content in search results by a significant margin. This approach is reflective of Google's commitment to ensuring that users receive the most informative, reliable, and contextually relevant search results.

Integrating AI and Human Insight for Effective SEO Marketing

The implications for SEO and marketing are profound. AI content, while useful for certain applications, can be detrimental if relied upon exclusively. It lacks the intrinsic human qualities—emotion, personal insight, and a deep understanding of context—that often resonate with readers and drive engagement. For brands looking to establish a substantial online presence, integrating a human-centric approach in content creation is becoming not just beneficial but essential.

Consider the impact of user engagement on SEO. Content that connects with users on a personal level is more likely to be shared, discussed, and linked to. These are key signals that Google’s algorithms consider when ranking content. Therefore, even if AI can assist in the mechanical aspects of content creation, the strategic and creative input needs to be distinctly human.

Balancing AI Efficiency with Human Creativity in Google SEO

So, where does this leave marketers in terms of using AI for SEO? It's a tool, not a replacement. AI can help streamline the content creation process, provide data-driven insights, and even suggest content adjustments based on performance analytics. However, the core of your content strategy should focus on creating genuine, insightful, and engaging content that reflects your brand’s voice and meets your audience's needs.

In conclusion, while AI-generated content is not inherently bad, it requires a careful approach to ensure it aligns with Google’s quality guidelines. As Google continues to refine its algorithms, the value of the human touch in content creation remains undiminished. For anyone looking to excel in SEO and digital marketing, balancing the efficiency of AI with the irreplaceable insight of human creativity is the key to success. How will you adapt your strategies to thrive in this changing landscape?

If your business performance can be improved, reach out to the Leaders in Digital team to fix it. We can also help you create a strategic SEO strategy that will keep your site ranking and generating conversions.

In a recent groundbreaking move, Google announced two major updates designed to enhance the quality of its search results and dramatically shift the landscape for SEO marketing managers and content creators. Here's a closer look at what has changed and how it might affect your online presence.

Major Updates from Google

Last month, Google rolled out significant changes to its search engine algorithm, aimed explicitly at reducing the prevalence of low-quality, unoriginal content cluttering its search results. The updates include:

1. A Core Algorithm Update: This major revision to the way Google indexes and ranks web pages is designed to prioritise high-quality, original content over the derivative and spammy material that often surfaces in search results.

2. Enhanced Spam Policies: Alongside the algorithm update, Google has introduced stricter spam policies to crack down on manipulative content practices, ensuring a cleaner, more valuable search experience for users.

From their preliminary assessments, Google expects these new measures to decrease the visibility of substandard content by up to 40%. Notably, this crackdown targets a large volume of AI-generated content, which has become increasingly prevalent as marketers search for quick, scalable content solutions.

The Impact on Websites

The implications of these updates are significant. Numerous websites have already felt the sting, with Google imposing search ranking penalties on those failing to meet the new quality standards. This has sent a wave of concern through the digital marketing community, as many rely heavily on automated content generation tools.

How We Can Help

If you've noticed a sudden drop in your website's search performance, it's crucial to act swiftly to regain your footing in Google's rankings. My team and I specialize in navigating these turbulent waters. We can help you assess the impact of the algorithm update on your site, identify the content that’s hurting your rankings, and make the necessary adjustments to align with Google’s new standards.

Moreover, we don’t just stop at damage control. Our expertise extends to developing robust content strategies that not only recover lost rankings but also safeguard your site against future penalties. By focusing on originality, quality, and value, we can help ensure that your site not only survives but thrives under the new regime.

Free SEO Audit

The path forward in this new SEO landscape can be challenging, but you don’t have to navigate it alone. Contact me, Dawn, and the LiD Team, and let us help you turn these changes into opportunities for growth. Together, we can craft a content strategy that stands the test of time and changes in Google’s algorithms, ensuring your site remains at the forefront of search results.

With these enhancements, your business can continue to excel in a digital environment that values quality and authenticity above all. Don't let algorithm changes derail your digital success—let us know if we can help you grow your business through Google and SEO Marketing starting with a FREE Seo Audit.

Best regards,

Dawn & the LiD Team

bottom of page